Why does my flip_bit function return the wrong number?


Why does my flip_bit function return the wrong number?


There are a few common mistakes with this exercise that are listed below:
Make sure your mask is created by shifting a 1 left by n - 1 digits. If we shift by n, that is one too many, since the 1 starts off in the first position.
The result you return is the result of XORing together the number passed to the function and the mask you just created.
Be sure to wrap the result in bin() when you return it!

Ok, cool, now help me here.

def flip_bit(number, n):
  bit_to_flip = 0b1 << (n -1)  #Ok now how to explain that? Flip the nth bit .
  result = number ^ bit_to_flip #(with the ones bit being the first bit) and store it in result
  return bin(result)

why ,nth bit, = (n-1) where is that come from? 0b1 is the first bit, and then we are selecting the bit to flip, but why like this? (n-1)?

As you said correctly: 0b1 is the first bit. So it is already given. If you want to flip the 10th bit (like in the example) you have to subtract 1 from 10. If you would not do so, you would end up at the 11th bit.

in the exercise it is asking you to flip the 10th bit.

what I don’t understand is how this is possible? I thought the max amount of bits at any one time we 8 (due to base 2)?


[1]β€”[1]β€”[0]β€”[0]β€”[1]β€”[1]β€”[0]β€”[0] = 204 for example

If I were to convert this code into Python 3-appropriate syntax, how would I deal with the β€˜n’ paramater? I ran it inside Repl.it and tried to tweak accordingly:

def flip_bit(number,n):
 bit_flipper = 0b1 << (n-1)
 result = bit_flipper ^ number
 return bin(result)
print (flip_bit(0b1001))

but kept getting the following error:

Any insight would be greatly appreciated! :smile:

you are calling the flip_bit function with only one argument


I think you are thinking of bytes (usually composed of 8 bits), not base 2 (base 2 is just a counting method used by bytes, like base 10 is the counting method most people use in ordinary life outside of programming).

A bit is just a 0 or a 1 when used in binary (base 2) counting, there is no limit on how many places the number can extend to. Just like in normal base ten counting, you can count up as high as you like in base 2 to express any integer number, using however many places are necessary to do so.


Why couldn’t you have started at the 0th bit and shifted the nth bit instead of starting at the 1st bit and shifting the (n-1 )th bit?

Left shifting is the same as multiplying by 2. 0 * 2 == 0. The n-1 is more about accounting for the starting bit.

just asking is the intended result for the function 0b1000001, the program wanted me to get 0b101
from the argument of (0b111,2) but the result is way bigger.

Just wondering, do we have to use XOR operator in this exercise or we can use OR operator instead? I don’t know why OR operator makes more sense to me :thinking:

def flip_bit(number,n):
  mask = 0b01 << (n - 1)
  result = number ^ mask
  print bin(result)
print flip_bit(0b111, 2)

its givingback β€œnone”


Given there is no return statement, Python returns, None. Try to return the result and let the print at the caller handle the output.

working cheers for that

1 Like